VFD or Phase Converter?

Intro

Variable frequency drives (VFDs) and phase converters enable the operation of motors and other three phase loads from single phase utility services. Here's a comparison of key factors to consider when selecting between the two:

‍

Multiple Load Capability

Phase converters can operate multiple loads, whereas VFDs are generally limited to single load operation. Converters can handle motors of varying HP ratings and can run multiple motors either separately or simultaneously. Properly sized rotary converters can manage unlimited quantities of motors operating at the same time.

Ease of Operation and Maintenance‍

VFDs present greater challenges in both operation and maintenance compared to converters, which are simpler to use.

Harmonics‍

Phase converters generate no harmonics as they use linear components, unlike VFDs, which can introduce harmonics into single phase lines.

Serviceability‍

Phase converters can be serviced by many motor repair shops and electrical distributors, while VFDs typically need to be sent to authorized repair stations for service.

Cost Efficiency‍

Converters do not require line or load reactors, unlike many VFDs, reducing added costs.

Simplicity‍

Converters are easy to install and maintain, particularly in remote and rural locations, requiring only basic electrical tools and knowledge.

Surge Resistance‍

Converters are generally unaffected by utility line surges, whereas VFDs are more vulnerable to lightning storms, power surges, and voltage fluctuations.

Environmental Resilience‍

Converters are usually NEMA 3R rated out of the box and are less susceptible to temperature and weather extremes.

Optimal Solutions‍

Combining a converter and VFD can provide a robust solution if speed change is needed along with rugged power conversion.

Special Loads‍

Converters can power DC drives from three phase power, UPS systems, and resistive loads like heating, applications for which VFDs are unsuitable.

Overview

• No Speed Change Needed: Choose a converter.
• Motors Over 10 HP: Choose a converter.
• Easy Service, Installation, and Maintenance: Choose a converter.
• Multiple Motors (e.g., lift stations): Choose a converter.
• Special Loads: Consider phase converters.
• Longevity: Converters are durable and reliable, akin to "taking a licking and keep on ticking."

For more information on RONK's line of phase converters, contact our sales team at 1-800-221-7665.